Thursday, March 31, 2011

Fixing a Flat Cookie

The pictures don't do a great job of illustrating my tips, but know that there is a difference in the cookies, even if the photo doesn't show it.

Do you ever get flat cookies and you have no idea why?  After all, you followed the recipe exactly.


Let me give you a couple tips I have learned through trial and error.

First off, use real butter, not margarine. If you use margarine, you will have a flat cookie. Second, let your butter soften naturally. Do not use the microwave. I don't understand the science of it all, but there is a noticable difference.

If you find that your first batch is flat, there is no need to fear.


You can thicken up your cookies. All you have to do is add some flour. I might add just a 1/4 of a cup to see if that does the trick.

I made at least 20 dozen cookies last week and was weak and didn't follow some of my own advice on the microwave (only on one of the batches). I noticed right away the problem and added some flour. I made sure to blend thoroughly.

1st batch:


Add flour batch:


Side-by-side comparison:


Can you see the difference. I promise, there was one. Now if you find you've added too much flour, no problem. Just add another egg to even it out. I learned this trick from a BYU-Idaho head baker.

Give it a try and let me know how it goes.

6 comments: said...

thanks for the suggestions!

Tanya said...

Mmm, I love them slightly underbaked, and collapsed flat on themselves, but I'll keep your tips in mind when baking for others (=

Sadie said...

Great suggestion! :) Thanks for sharing.


Rebecca @ My Girlish Whims said...

thanks for the tip!! this ALWAYS happens to me :-/

PS: I'm doing a giveaway on my blog for $20 to my etsy shop, stop by and enter if you like pretty jewelry! :)

SJ @ Homemaker On A Dime said...

Hi, Lyndee! You've got great ideas. Would you like to show them off, meet excellent bloggers, and increase your followers in the process? If yes, please join our Creative Bloggers' Party & Hop.

It's easy to join. All you have to do is 1) link up whatever creative post you'd like to share - can be a DIY project, decor, photography,crafts, recipes, poem, thrifty finds, or that informative syndicated post that can
make us laugh, or cry - in short, whatever you're proud of! 2) Then follow as many blogs as your heart desires, preferably starting first with the one before you and after you, before branching out.

You’re not even required to include the party button – you read that right – not required to include the party button but if you’re so inclined display it in your blog or your post, you’re very much welcome to do so :)

Please join us at

Sweet Peas and Bumblebees said...

Thanks for the tips!!

I would love it if you would link it up to our What I Made Wednesday Linky Party!!

Also, stop in for a chance to win our 100 Follower Giveaway {{Beaded Watch & Hobby Lobby Gift Card}}

Sweet Peas and Bumblebees